Elon Musk’s Starlink doesn’t compete with your cable modem


poster starlink

Elon Musk’s Starlink satellite tv for pc broadband has raised some ungrounded expectations of broadband liberation, however the SpaceX founder’s onscreen speak at Cellular World Congress (MWC) Barcelona knocked them out of orbit and right into a fiery reentry—or it ought to have, besides that hope dies exhausting amongst folks determined for higher connectivity.

“You’ll be able to consider Starlink as filling within the gaps between 5G and fiber, and actually entering into components of the world which might be hardest to achieve,” he advised interviewer Justin Springham, writer of Mobile World Live, in a keynote Tuesday on the wi-fi trade commerce present. As in, the final “3%, perhaps 5%.”

Musk has supplied caveats like these earlier than, similar to in his keynote on the Satellite tv for pc 2020 convention final March in Washington. However his digital look at MWC yielded different grounds for warning, each in what he stated and what he didn’t.


Launching all of Starlink’s low-earth-orbit satellites—Musk stated greater than 1,500 are actually in service—more and more seems like the better a part of getting the service deployed, due to the more and more low launch prices of SpaceX’s Falcon 9 rocket. That largely reusable automobile now dominates the industrial launch market and helps transport astronauts to the Worldwide Area Station.

“Final 12 months, I consider SpaceX delivered about two-thirds of all payload to orbit,” Musk stated of SpaceX’s success with the Falcon 9, which may deploy 60 Starlink satellites in a single launch. The Hawthorne, California, agency has been touchdown first phases of this two-stage rocket for reuse since 2015 and now retrieves and recycles the fairings that shield its cargo within the decrease environment. “The price of mass to orbit can also be the bottom it’s ever been.”

However though these Starlink satellites, about 550 kilometers up, mix to ship some 30 terabits per second and will supply worldwide protection aside from polar areas by August, Musk warned that this doesn’t essentially depart a lot bandwidth for particular person subscribers. Particularly in the event that they stay too shut collectively.

“It’s actually meant for sparsely populated areas,” Musk advised Springham, who appeared onstage in Barcelona as a part of the hybrid format MWC adopted after the pandemic pressured its abrupt cancellation final 12 months. Starlink service within the present beta-test program prices $99 a month for obtain speeds marketed at 50 to 150 Mbps; beta testers have largely confirmed these obtain speeds whereas reporting uploads within the vary of 20 Mbps.

Early critiques

A lot of Starlink’s early adopters have supplied effusive endorsements, however the service’s setup and reliability have induced points for others. In a evaluate, The Verge’s Nilay Patel called Starlink “very a lot a beta product that’s unreliable, inconsistent, and foiled by even the merest suggestion of timber.”

In its beta state, Starlink doesn’t implement knowledge caps, however SpaceX and Musk have avoided confirming that this can proceed to be the case when Starlink enters full service. Springham didn’t attempt to pin Musk down on this Tuesday.


Musk didn’t supply a subscriber whole extra particular than a joking remark that Starlink had “not too long ago handed the strategically notable variety of 69,420 lively customers.”

He additionally did not reveal what number of of Starlink’s compact satellite tv for pc dish receivers had been deployed however confirmed that everyone who paid the $499 listing value acquired an distinctive deal (with the potential unspoken exception of customers in sizzling climates who’ve not too long ago discovered their receivers overheating).

“That terminal prices us greater than $1,000,” Musk stated. “Promoting terminals at half-price just isn’t super-compelling at scale.”

Starlink is engaged on cheaper designs that Musk hopes will convey the associated fee all the way down to $350 and even $250.

It’s additionally planning to launch upgraded satellites. A model 1.5 mannequin will quickly add “satellite-to-satellite laser hyperlinks” to make sure steady connectivity, addressing one other topic of some early complaints; Musk known as a 2.0 satellite tv for pc design due subsequent 12 months “considerably extra succesful” with out elaborating.

Large-ticket broadband

All of this effort has already price SpaceX billions of {dollars}, Musk advised Springham. It must spend billions extra earlier than Starlink can flip money circulation optimistic based mostly on each particular person subscriptions and offers with telecom corporations to assist fill out their networks in “probably the most troublesome to serve 3% to five% of the client base”—normally rural areas.

“It’ll be at the very least $5 billion, and perhaps as a lot as 10,” he stated of Starlink’s price range. “It’s quite a bit.”

Step primary for Starlink is don’t go bankrupt.”

Starlink must spend one other $10 or $20 billion in a while, Musk added, to remain aggressive with the slower however extra extensively accessible service of satellites in geosynchronous orbit, 5G wi-fi companies and competing low-earth-orbit companies like OneWeb.

(By the use of comparision, NASA budgeted $2.7 billion on its Mars Perseverance rover.)

On the similar time, SpaceX can also be funding Starship, the totally reusable two-stage rocket designed to hold 100 tons of cargo to low Earth orbit after which make moon and Mars settlements viable. Musk stated SpaceX hopes to stage Starship’s first orbital check launch “within the subsequent few months.”

Musk’s feedback on that bold venture ought to have reminded all people watching how comparatively modest his personal fundamental objective for Starlink appear.


“Each different low earth orbit constellation ever completed has gone bankrupt,” Musk stated early within the half-hour speak, citing such previous collapses as Iridium. “Step primary for Starlink is don’t go bankrupt.”